Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: Different kinds of B12 tests

  1. #1
    Ex-admin Korn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Europe
    Posts
    4,830

    Default Different kinds of B12 tests

    From http://vegweb.com/articles/anai-1038161917.shtml

    "Question: Hi, In terms of determining B12 level is a red blood cell count sufficient when having a blood test or should it be specifically tested for B12 levels? Thanks, Gaye

    Answer: Simple blood tests can determine if you have too little of this important vitamin. Print this article or add the following to the list of questions you plan to bring to your next visit:

    Vitamin B12 and Folic Acid tests: Two of the most common causes of enlarged red blood cells - that result in Macrocytic anemia, are low blood levels of vitamin B12 and folic acid.
    A Schilling test: This urine test is done to help determine whether the body is absorbing B12 and the actual cause of why it may not be.
    Homocysteine: Homocysteine is an amino acid normally found in minute amounts in the blood. A high blood level of homocysteine is a sign of B12 deficiency anemia.
    Complete Blood Count (CBC): This blood test can easily spot problems with low levels of B12 by examining red blood cell count for anemia. It checks the red blood cells for shape, size, and quantity.
    Methylmalonic acid (MMA) blood test: Methylmalonic acid is a substance in blood that increases when vitamin B12 levels decrease.

    Be sure to ask your doctor for a copy of the lab results. Most labs will offer a normal and abnormal range value next to the result for reference. Having the results will help ease your mind and also can be reviewed against future lab results.

    Anai Rhoads"
    I will not eat anything that walks, swims, flies, runs, skips, hops or crawls.

  2. #2
    Pooh
    Guest

    Default

    From what I have seen, MMA tests are considered the most reliable of these tests, but here is an article (pdf-file) that questions it as the only marker for diagnosis of B-12 deficiency.

  3. #3
    Ex-admin Korn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Europe
    Posts
    4,830

    Default

    Here is some more info on different B12 tests. The reason this is interesting, is that if you just call your doctor and ask for a B12 test, there is a big chance that she or he is not well informed about which tests that are most reliable. Many vegans have come across doctors that know little or nothing about nutrition, B12, MMA etc. Since 'good' levels in a normal B12 blood doesn't necessarily mean that you get enough B12 (and vice versa), testing for homocysteine and B12 in blood and MMA in urine seems to be the best way to get reliable levels.

    From http://www.b12.com/umma.htm:

    "UMMA TEST: THE CHOICE OVER OTHER TESTS


    SERUM B12 ASSAY



    1. Falsely positive serum B12 tests (low levels in the absence of B12 deficiency)
    Study shows assay to have only a 22.2% positive predictive value. After a five-year follow up on low serum B12 levels nearly 4 of 5 individuals were without clinical evidence of B12 deficiency.17,18
    Of 504 patients with low serum B12, only 22% (109) had clinically important deficiency.26
    Of 47 subjects with low serum B12 only 7 (15%) were shown to be clinically B12 deficient.17,18
    About 20-40% of elderly people with low serum vitamin B12 levels have completely normal metabolic status 1,2 and cannot be regarded as B12 deficient.
    "Because low cobalamin concentrations can occur in the absence of deficiency, the term "cobalamin deficiency" should probably be reserved for those cases with accompanying clinical or metabolic evidence supporting the diagnosis". 2
    For clarification, there is an inexact relationship between serum B12 and cellular B12 since the total serum B12 is bound to three carriers proteins: transcobalamin-I (TC-I),TC II and TC III. Only TC-II, which carries less than 20% of the serum B12, delivers B12 to the tissues. Measurement of TC-II levels have not been proven to be an accurate indicator of tissue B12 deficiency 6 and the assay is not a functional test.

    2. Falsely negative serum B12 tests (normal levels in the presence of B12 deficiency)
    Of 35 seniors with high UMMA, 49% had a normal serum B12 level.14
    Subjects (14%) found B12 deficient showed equal numbers with serum B12 < 200 pg/ml (below normal) and between 200 and 300 pg/ml. 27 Accordingly, MMA testing was recommended for individuals with serum B12 levels < 350 pg/ml .28 However, another study advised against serum MMA (SMMA) testing subjects with low normal serum B12 since huge numbers of non B12 deficient individuals would be caught in the net.2 This dilemma illustrates the need to use the accurate UMMA test.
    Of 23 vegetarians identified with high UMMA, 83% (19/23) had normal serum B12 levels.5
    Asymptomatic patients and healthy volunteers with normal B12 levels but elevated MMA have been reported. 1,2,5,14,27-32
    Five geriatric patients with normal serum B12 levels and suspected Alzheimer's dementia, were reported successfully reversed with intramuscular B12. The lower limit of vitamin B12 in Japan and some European countries is 500 pg/mL, which is based on neurological criteria.32



    Serum MMA test



    1. Falsely positive serum MMA tests
    Norman and Cronin documented reports of the SMMA assay yielding falsely positive results in conditions of renal insufficiency, thyroid disease, pregnancy, small bowel bacterial overgrowth, hemoconcentration, and for unexplained reasons.33
    Renal insufficiency was associate with 25.5% of all abnormal SMMA levels in one survey of 725 individuals over age 60. Carmel et. al 2 recommend renal insufficiency must be considered in evaluation high SMMA levels.
    A study concludes that plasma creatinine must be included when assessing SMMA levels, even within the normal range.34



    2. Falsely negative serum MMA tests
    The serum MMA test was found less sensitive than the urinary MMA assay. In a study of suspected B12 deficient vegetarians, the SMMA test (normal = 73-271 nm/L) identified 5 of 8 (63%) whereas the UMMA (normal < 4.0) assay detected 7 of 8 (88%). UMMA levels normalized with B12 therapy but not all SMMA levels. Serum B12 levels supported the UMMA test as being valid .20 Although the numbers are small, this article indicates that if large numbers of individuals are tested, many individuals with neurologic manifestations may be missed without using the UMMA assay.



    Serum Homocysteine



    Published data show that serum Hcys levels are rarely, if ever, needed in addition to MMA levels to diagnose B12 deficiency. Reevaluating published data that listed both SMMA and Hcys using the current normal value for SMMA, of 37 B12 deficient patients, all were identified with high SMMA levels.22 Of 78 patients reported B12 deficient using SMMA and Hcys, 77 were identified by high SMMA The remaining patient with high serum Hcys was folate deficient, which could account for the high Hcys level.35
    In an UMMA screening study, serum Hcys levels were above normal in only 9 of 16 subjects (14). SMMA rose in gastrectomized rats within two months after surgery whereas Hcys did not become elevated until ten months after surgery 36 and rats feed a B12 deficient diet showed elevated SMMA after 3 months but normal Hcys after 7 months.37 In nine vegetarians with high UMMA and /or low serum B12 levels, all had normal Hcys levels (Normal = 5.1-13.9 mol/L). 20 Serum Hcys levels are also elevated by folate deficiency as well as numerous other conditions.6




    SCHILLING TEST



    The Schilling test can be falsely normal in individuals who are unable to absorb food-bound vitamin B12 but can absorb crystalline B12.38

    UMMA TEST



    1. Falsely positive
    In a double blinded prospective clinical evaluation of the UMMA test, the assay was reported to have a specificity of 99%.17 However, the one patient reported to have falsely high UMMA of 9.5 (normal <5.0) did not have a follow up UMMA test after B12 therapy and therefore was most likely tissue deficient without overt clinical evidence.
    Of 16 subjects with elevated UMMA, all had normal MMA after B12 IM. (p<.001).14 Of 7 subjects with high UMMA all normalized with B12 therapy.20 Other studies noting high UMMA 5,9-11,39,40 demonstrate reductions of MMA with effective therapy and no problem with falsely high UMMA.



    2. Falsely negative
    The UMMA test identified non-anemic elderly individuals 14 and asymptomatic vegetarians 5 as B12 deficient. UMMA normalized with adequate B12 therapy. Normal serum B12 was found in 49% of the non-anemic elderly (normal UMMA<5.0) and 83% of the vegetarian population. (normal UMMA<4.0). These individual may have been missed using the conventional serum B12 assay. These data demonstrate that there is no problem with falsely negative UMMA and there is no study to date reporting falsely negative UMMA.



    CONCLUSION:

    The Mayo Clinic Proceedings spotlighted the UMMA test as preferred because of convenience and sensitivity. 41
    In recent comparative studies, the UMMA test was found more sensitive than the serum B12 assay 5 or the SMMA test.20
    A study found that patients with neurologic disturbances excreted larger amounts of UMMA than those without neurologic disorders 42 and recommend the UMMA assay use to attenuate an important cause of permanent neurologic disability.43
    The UMMA test reflects tissue/cellular vitamin B12 deficiency and is the leading candidate as the "gold standard" assay for identifying tissue B12 deficiency.19,21"
    I will not eat anything that walks, swims, flies, runs, skips, hops or crawls.

  4. #4
    Ex-admin Korn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Europe
    Posts
    4,830

    Default Re: Different kinds of B12 tests

    From http://www.aafp.org/afp/20030301/979.html


    Diagnosis of vitamin B12 deficiency is typically based on measurement of serum vitamin B12 levels; however, about 50 percent of patients with subclinical disease have normal B12 levels.
    This means that if you have a B12 test only, and the results show that the B12 levels in the blood is fine, you may still have a 'subclinical disease'.

    This also applies to studies on B12 levels in meat eaters...

Similar Threads

  1. MMA (Methylmalonic Acid) tests
    By Korn in forum Vegans and B12
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: May 2nd, 2011, 11:13 AM
  2. Red Meat 'Raises Risk of All Kinds of Death'
    By Gorilla in forum Human evolution and environmental issues
    Replies: 16
    Last Post: Mar 27th, 2009, 01:58 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •